Planning a family getaway to the Balearic Islands for August 2025? The choice between Menorca and Mallorca can significantly impact your budget and experience. This comprehensive cost analysis helps you make an informed decision, with real prices and practical insights for families traveling during peak season.
Flight Costs & Accessibility
Mallorca's Palma Airport (PMI) offers more competitive prices due to higher flight frequency. For August 2025, expect to pay €200-300 per person from major European cities like London (British Airways, easyJet), Berlin (Eurowings), or Paris (Air France). Menorca Airport (MAH) typically commands a 15-20% premium, with prices ranging from €250-350 per person. Both Ryanair and Vueling serve both islands, often offering family-friendly morning departure times.
Accommodation Comparison
Mallorca offers a wider range of family accommodations but comes with higher peak-season prices in popular areas. A family of four can expect to pay:
Mallorca:
- 4-star beach resort in Alcúdia: €280-350/night
- Family apartment in Puerto Pollensa: €200-250/night
- Villa with pool in Cala d'Or: €350-450/night
Menorca:
- 4-star resort in Son Bou: €220-280/night
- Family apartment in Cala Galdana: €180-220/night
- Villa with pool in Binibeca: €300-400/night
Family-Friendly Areas
- Mallorca: Port de Pollensa, Alcúdia, Cala d'Or (busier, more amenities)
- Menorca: Son Bou, Cala Galdana, Arenal d'en Castell (quieter, more laid-back)
- Both islands have excellent beach safety records and clear, shallow waters
Activity Costs
Mallorca typically has higher activity prices but more options. Average costs for a family of four:
Mallorca:
- Waterparks (Western Water Park): €120
- Palma Aquarium: €85
- Boat trips: €180-250
Menorca:
- Aqua Center water park: €80
- Glass-bottom boat tours: €140
- Horse riding excursions: €160
Dining Expenses
Menorca offers better value for dining, with average meal costs 15-20% lower than Mallorca. Family meal averages:
Mallorca:
- Casual restaurant dinner: €80-100
- Beach club lunch: €100-130
- Local café breakfast: €35-45
Menorca:
- Restaurant dinner: €65-85
- Beachfront lunch: €70-90
- Café breakfast: €25-35
Transport Costs
Car rental is recommended for both islands. August 2025 rates:
- Mallorca: €65-80/day for a family car
- Menorca: €55-70/day for a family car
Fuel costs are similar on both islands, but Menorca's smaller size means lower overall transport expenses.
Total Budget Comparison
One-week holiday budget for a family of four in August 2025:
Mallorca:
- Mid-range: €3,500-4,500
- Luxury: €5,000-7,000
Menorca:
- Mid-range: €3,000-4,000
- Luxury: €4,500-6,000
Money-Saving Tips
- Book accommodations by January 2025 for best rates (30-40% savings)
- Consider all-inclusive resorts in Mallorca's Alcúdia or Menorca's Son Bou
- Use local supermarkets like Mercadona for self-catering
- Book activities online in advance for 10-15% discounts
- Travel mid-week for better flight prices (typically 20% cheaper)
Final Verdict
For families in August 2025, Menorca offers better overall value with savings of 15-20% compared to Mallorca. Choose Menorca for a quieter, more budget-friendly experience with excellent beaches and sufficient activities. Opt for Mallorca if you prefer more entertainment options and don't mind paying a premium for additional amenities and attractions.
