Choosing between train and plane travel from Nashville to New Orleans requires weighing numerous factors beyond just ticket prices. This comprehensive guide analyzes real costs, actual travel times, and genuine experiences for both options in 2024, helping you make an informed decision for your journey between these iconic Southern cities.
Quick Comparison Overview
- Train: 27-28 hours total journey time, typically $120-180 one-way
- Plane: 3.5-4.5 hours total journey time (including airport procedures), usually $150-300 one-way
- Train requires connection in Chicago via City of New Orleans route
- Direct flights available on Southwest Airlines and American Airlines
The Train Journey Experience
Taking Amtrak from Nashville to New Orleans requires a connection in Chicago, as there's no direct service between these cities. You'll need to take the following routes: First, board the Amtrak bus from Nashville to Memphis (4 hours), then take the City of New Orleans train from Memphis to New Orleans (approximately 8 hours). The full journey typically costs between $120-180 for a coach seat, with roomettes starting at $350 for private accommodations.
- Coach seats offer 39-inch pitch with footrests and reclining capabilities
- Dining car serves full meals (included for sleeper car passengers, additional cost for coach)
- Free Wi-Fi available but can be spotty in rural areas
- Two free checked bags up to 50 lbs each
- Power outlets at every seat
Flying Between Nashville and New Orleans
Direct flights operate between Nashville International Airport (BNA) and Louis Armstrong New Orleans International Airport (MSY). Southwest Airlines offers 2-3 daily flights, while American Airlines typically operates 1-2 daily flights. The actual flight time is approximately 1 hour and 45 minutes.
- Southwest: Usually $150-250 round trip with two free checked bags
- American Airlines: Typically $180-300 round trip, baggage fees extra ($30 first bag)
- Flight schedules vary seasonally with more options during peak travel periods
- Both airlines operate Boeing 737s on this route
Real Door-to-Door Transit Times
For accurate comparison, consider total transit time from downtown Nashville to the French Quarter in New Orleans:
- Train: 27-28 hours total (including bus connection and transfers)
- Plane: 4.5 hours total (45 min to airport, 2 hours before flight, 1.75 hour flight, 45 min to French Quarter)
- Train stations are typically closer to city centers than airports
- Airport security and check-in add significant time to air travel
Hidden Costs Analysis
Beyond base ticket prices, consider these additional expenses for each mode:
- Train extras: Meals ($10-25 per meal), roomette upgrade ($170-250 additional)
- Plane extras: Baggage fees (except Southwest), airport parking ($18-24/day at BNA), airport transfers ($20-35 each way)
- Train parking at stations: Usually $5-10 per day
- Airline seat selection fees: $15-45 on American Airlines (free on Southwest)
Comfort and Amenities Comparison
Each mode offers distinct comfort levels and amenities worth considering:
- Train: More legroom, ability to walk around, scenic views through Mississippi
- Plane: Faster journey, newer aircraft with modern entertainment systems
- Train dining: Full-service dining car with table service
- Plane dining: Limited buy-on-board options ($8-15 for snacks and light meals)
Booking Strategy and Timing
To secure the best fares, consider these booking strategies:
- Train tickets: Book 2-3 months ahead for best prices and roomette availability
- Flights: Book 3-4 months ahead for optimal rates, especially during peak seasons
- Train fares typically stay steady, with less seasonal variation
- Flight prices spike during Mardi Gras (February/March) and Jazz Fest (April/May)
Environmental Impact
Train travel produces significantly lower carbon emissions per passenger than flying. The train journey emits approximately 0.1 pounds of CO2 per passenger mile, compared to approximately 0.4 pounds per passenger mile for flights on this route.
Final Recommendations
Choose the train if: You enjoy scenic travel, have time to spare, want to avoid airport hassles, or are traveling with lots of luggage. Choose flying if: Time is your priority, you're traveling during good weather seasons, or you find a competitive fare on Southwest with included baggage.
